Year of the Comet
Comet C/2011 L4 (PANSTARRS)

PANSTARRS information

Comet C/2012 S1 (ISON)

ISON information

Dave's Universe Videos
E-mail Article to a FriendPrint ArticleBookmark and Share

Dave's Universe: Truth and science

In this first of a series of "Dave’s Universe" videos, Editor David J. Eicher explores the different methods that thinking people use to determine what they believe.

How do you determine what is true and what’s false about the universe? How do you know what really happened in the past? How many galaxies are out there? Why your cat suddenly seems dull and listless? What gave you that tremendous stomachache after eating at the low-end sushi joint?

Humans have always used a variety of methods of choosing their beliefs about the universe around them — of deciding on, in squishy humanistic language, their “world view.” You know, what to believe and what not to believe. And the choices are more varied and confusing than ever before, now that we live in a 24/7 world of overblown media hype, faux news, exaggerated claims, posturing, economic uncertainty, and institutional paranoia.

Every one of us uses each of the four basic methods in different ways and at different times. They range from the simple-minded and silly — intuition — to increasingly sophisticated methods: authoritarianism, rational methods, and finally, the basis of science, empirical observation and experimentation.

User Comments
Be the first to leave your comment below!

Only registered members of Astronomy.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Register Today!
 
5 stars
EDWARD ENZ from CALIFORNIA said:
Dave, this was an excellent presentation of "Truth". Science strives for "Truth"; all other human endeavors are usually compromised by bias and outright fraud.
5 stars
JOHN BORJE from CALIFORNIA said:
Mention Karl Popper's definition of "Science" as the last say so after
the advance to "empirical observation and experimentation." In a nut
shell, his definition is that science is that which can always be
disproved. In other words, if a statement cannot be otherwise, then
it is not science. Science is that which can always be otherwise, else
it's not science.
JOHN A JOSEPH from MICHIGAN said:
I believe the Universe is unending and no one can prove it's not.
4 stars
DENIS PERRY from NEW YORK said:
Interesting, but i'm going to have to perform some evaluational experiments on this subject before I conclude whether to believe this viewpoint or not!
5 stars
CYRIL KOZAK from NEW YORK said:
A wonderful defense for the scientific method that seeks to explain the mechanism/how of physical truth. Yes we should all be patient and understand it's noble persuit of truth. As for Philosophy and Theology, their persuit is to answer why. It is unfortunate that in the "Dark Ages" there was confusion between the two and science seemed to be feared. I encourage you to vigorously pursue and defend the pursuit of scientific truth and the how of our existence. Please be patient with the Philosophical and Theological pusuit of the why of our existence.
4 stars
RICHARD MCNALLY from MARYLAND said:
Excellent! I couldn't help but be reminded of Carl Sagan's "The Demon Haunted World" while listening to your arguments for the scientific method over dogma and mysticism. Your recent, yet necessary stance on America's lacking state of science education these days continues to strike a nerve.
5 stars
ROBERT M POWELL from WISCONSIN said:
Well put!
5 stars
AUDREY FISCHER from ILLINOIS said:
Thanks Dave, Please keep these coming. I would love to see all Astronomy's regularly featured authors each have a monthly audio... either adding more related info, or simply reading/ or paraphrasing in their own voice their most currant article... with possibly a sneak peak of next month's article. This keeps it up-close & personal. That's another reason you are so fondly thought of around the country. You are constantly accessible and familiar.... and (it's obvious that) we LIKE what we SEE and HEAR from you. Looking forward to that jam-fest rock-out with Astronomy's Blues Band at ALCon2012. cheers+stars!
SEARCH SITE
Subscriber Only Access
Subscriber Only Content
Look for this icon. This denotes premium subscriber content. Learn more »
Become a Member of Astronomy.com
Register today for access to more valuable resource information.
Interact in our forums, comment on articles, receive our newsletter and much more!
Not a member?
Subscriber and Member Login
Password
Remember me